Paper: arXiv 2611.25762

Authors: Khizar Qureshi

Abstract

An institution must complete a portfolio adjustment, but traders who prepare inventory for it can choose whether to participate. We study how public forecasts affect the institution’s cost in a Bayesian execution game with optional activation, transient impact, and uniform-price terminal completion. The curvature of equilibrium cost as a function of the posterior target mean determines the value of information. In the scalar model, information benefits every fixed participation roster. Optional supply can reverse this ranking at entry, at full participation, and in a smooth interior with lognormal activation costs. For centered scalar targets, information weakly lowers cost relative to no information, strictly when the posterior mean is nonzero with positive probability. Centered Gaussian precision gains are always beneficial. An exact symmetric finite-population equilibrium identifies how information resolution and individual strategic size interact near entry. A portfolio extension gives a matrix criterion for the fixed-roster ranking, which can fail under general cross-impact. Even with isotropic execution, shared activation allows equally accurate signals about target magnitude and composition to have opposite execution values under one unchanged prior. Intraday ETF price data is used to characterize target uncertainty and trading conditions without identifying activation or institutional costs.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 9.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 6.0/10
  • Quadrant: Holy Grail — high math complexity, high empirical rigor

Why this score: The paper presents a highly complex mathematical model for an execution game with optional activation. While it includes an empirical application using ETF data, the focus is more on characterizing conditions rather than rigorous backtesting of a trading strategy. The core contribution lies in its novel theoretical framework for information value in this specific game.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
    A["Research Goal: Analyze how public forecasts affect institution's cost in portfolio adjustment"] --> B{"Methodology: Bayesian Execution Game with Optional Activation"};
    B --> C["Inputs: Transient Impact, Uniform-Price Terminal Completion, Lognormal Activation Costs"];
    C --> D{"Computational Process: Scalar Model, Finite-Population Equilibrium, Portfolio Extension"};
    D --> E["Data/Inputs: Intraday ETF Price Data"];
    E --> F["Key Findings: Information value depends on target mean curvature, optional supply can reverse ranking, Gaussian precision gains always beneficial, cross-impact matters, target magnitude vs. composition signals have opposite execution values"];

Evidence Card

What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card

Proposes

The paper proposes a Bayesian execution game model with optional activation, transient impact, and uniform-price terminal completion to study how public forecasts affect an institution's trading cost.

Source sentence
We study how public forecasts affect the institution's cost in a Bayesian execution game with optional activation, transient impact, and uniform-price terminal completion.

Assumes 6

  • Traders may optionally activate inventory supply (optional activation). model
    Source sentence
    We study how public forecasts affect the institution's cost in a Bayesian execution game with optional activation, transient impact, and uniform-price terminal completion.
  • Price impact is transient rather than permanent. execution
    Source sentence
    We study how public forecasts affect the institution's cost in a Bayesian execution game with optional activation, transient impact, and uniform-price terminal completion.
  • The terminal completion price is uniform across participants. model
    Source sentence
    We study how public forecasts affect the institution's cost in a Bayesian execution game with optional activation, transient impact, and uniform-price terminal completion.
  • The analysis initially focuses on a scalar target model. model
    Source sentence
    In the scalar model, information benefits every fixed participation roster.
Show 2 more
  • Target distributions are centered (mean zero) in several results. statistical
    Source sentence
    For centered scalar targets, information weakly lowers cost relative to no information, strictly when the posterior mean is nonzero with positive probability.
  • Execution impact is isotropic in some extensions. execution
    Source sentence
    Even with isotropic execution, shared activation allows equally accurate signals about target magnitude and composition to have opposite execution values under one unchanged prior.

Data

  • Intraday ETF price data market-prices unknown
    multiple ETFs
    Source sentence
    Intraday ETF price data is used to characterize target uncertainty and trading conditions without identifying activation or institutional costs.
  • Five‑minute histories of 26 ETFs and benchmark proxies · Massive market-prices commercial
    2021‑11‑09 to 2026‑11‑13 · 26 geared ETFs and 5 benchmark proxies
    Source sentence
    J Data and empirical methods J.1 Common sample and product scope All five-minute histories begin on November 9, 2021 and end on November 13, 2026 for this study. The start is the latest first observation among the 26 geared ETFs and five benchmark proxies in the sample.
  • Daily share volume and dollar turnover panel · Massive market-prices commercial
    2024‑11‑18 to 2026‑11‑13 · 31 ETFs
    Source sentence
    O Share volume and dollar turnover O.1 Measurement on a common daily panel Daily unadjusted OHLC, share volume, VWAP, cash distributions, and splits are obtained from Massive (Massive, 2026). The balanced panel contains all 31 ETFs on 499 dates from November 18, 2024 through November 13, 2026.
  • Fama–French daily factor returns and additional industry factor · Kenneth French Data Library benchmark public
    US equities
    Source sentence
    and investment factors, together with momentum and the value-weighted electronic-equipment industry portfolio from the Kenneth French Data Library (French, 2026). These factors concern US listed equities and are appropriate broad risk descriptors for the equity benchmark families studied here.

Recognised sources: Kenneth French Data Library

Costs

Not modeled A trading or execution result is reported without costs.

Source sentence
Its small and variable close-related movements do not identify activation, causal impact, or institutional execution costs.

Finds 5

  • Information weakly lowers institutional cost relative to no information, and strictly lowers cost when the posterior mean is nonzero with positive probability. theoretical
    Source sentence
    For centered scalar targets, information weakly lowers cost relative to no information, strictly when the posterior mean is nonzero with positive probability.
  • Centered Gaussian precision gains are always beneficial for cost. theoretical
    Source sentence
    Centered Gaussian precision gains are always beneficial.
  • Positive curvature in the cost function occurs at one‑quarter participation but is absent at median participation states. theoretical
    Source sentence
    Positive curvature occurs at one-quarter participation but is absent at the displayed median states.
  • Joint forecasts improve on diagonal covariance forecasts, though the improvement does not establish a benefit from updating correlations. performance
    Source sentence
    Both rolling joint forecasts improve on diagonal covariance, but this comparison does not establish a benefit from updating correlations.
  • Frozen correlation forecasts improve on diagonal forecasts in both periods examined. performance
    Source sentence
    Frozen correlation improves on diagonal forecasts in both directions and periods.

Checked by others

Qualified by

  • The two square root laws of market impact and the role of sophisticated market participants (2023)
    On the question: How does participation rate affect the curvature of market impact or trading cost?
    Compare the findings

    This paper: Positive curvature in the cost function occurs at one‑quarter participation but is absent at median participation states.

    That paper: The impact is concave in the participation rate for fixed duration, under mild hypotheses on U.

    Both findings address curvature: A reports concave impact for fixed duration, while B finds positive curvature at 0.25 participation but not at median participation.

Code

No repository by the authors found in the paper.

Extracted 2026-11-20 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.

Cited References (41)

  1. Leveraged Exchange-Traded Funds with Market Closure and Frictions (2023)
  2. Equivalent Comparisons of Experiments (1953)
  3. Social Value of Public Information (2002)
  4. Linear Quadratic Stochastic Control Problems with Stochastic Terminal Constraint (2018)
  5. The Convergence Rate of Stochastic Tracking with Application to Optimal Execution (2026)
  6. A Mean-Field Game of Market Entry: Portfolio Liquidation with Trading Constraints — → 2403.10441
  7. Mean-field Liquidation Games with Market Drop-out — → 2303.05783
  8. Periodic Trading Activities in Financial Markets: Mean-field Liquidation Game with Major-Minor Players — → 2408.09505
and 33 more
  1. Mean Field Game of High-Frequency Anticipatory Trading — → 2404.18200
  2. Trading with the Crowd (2023)
  3. Strategic Execution in the Presence of an Uninformed Arbitrageur (2012)
  4. Optimal Execution Among N Traders With Transient Price Impact — → 2501.09638
  5. Optimal Execution in a Multiplayer Model of Transient Price Impact (2017)
  6. Optimal Index-Linked Rebalancing with Anticipatory Trading (2026)
  7. Preying on Leveraged ETFs (2026)
  8. Path-Dependence of Leveraged ETF Returns (2010)
  9. Do Leveraged ETFs Really Amplify Late-Day Returns and Volatility? (2018)
  10. TQQQ UltraPro QQQ : Summary Prospectus (2026)
  11. Unlock More From the Nasdaq-100 (2026)
  12. Broad-index product mandate and proxy documentation (2026)
  13. Why Does Public News Augment Information Asymmetries? (2020)
  14. Disclosure, Liquidity, and the Cost of Capital (1991)
  15. Sunshine Trading and Financial Market Equilibrium (1991)
  16. A Rothschild–Stiglitz Approach to Bayesian Persuasion (2016)
  17. Bayesian Persuasion (2011)
  18. The Simple Economics of Optimal Persuasion (2019)
  19. The Value of Information in Oligopoly with Endogenous Entry (2025)
  20. Liquidity Provision to Leveraged ETFs and Equity Options Rebalancing Flows: Evidence from End-of-Day Stock Prices (2022) — link
  21. The Market Impact of Predictable Flows: Evidence from Leveraged VIX Products (2021) — link
  22. Market Intraday Momentum — → ssrn-2440866
  23. Measuring Volatility with the Realized Range (2007) — link
  24. Strictly Proper Scoring Rules, Prediction, and Estimation (2007) — link
  25. Extended Trading Close: Equity Trader Alert 2022-15 and Frequently Asked Questions (2022) — link
  26. HistoricalDataBar : Field Definitions (2026) — link
  27. A Simple, Positive Semi-Definite, Heteroskedasticity and Autocorrelation Consistent Covariance Matrix (1987) — link
  28. Tests of Conditional Predictive Ability (2006) — link
  29. Cross-Sectional Variation of Intraday Liquidity, Cross-Impact, and Their Effect on Portfolio Execution (2022) — link
  30. Data Library: Daily Five Factors, Momentum, and 49 Industry Portfolios (2026) — link
  31. Stocks Data: Custom Bars, Dividends, and Splits (2026) — link
  32. Daily Semiconductor Bull and Bear 3X ETFs (2026) — link
  33. LQG Information Design (2025) — link

6 of 41 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2601 linked papers.