Paper: arXiv 2307.15599
Authors: Sergio Pulido, Mathieu Rosenbaum, Emmanouil Sfendourakis
Abstract
Volume imbalance in a limit order book is often considered as a reliable indicator for predicting future price moves. In this work, we seek to analyse the nuances of the relationship between prices and volume imbalance. To this end, we study a market-making problem which allows us to view the imbalance as an optimal response to price moves. In our model, there is an underlying efficient price driving the mid-price, which follows the model with uncertainty zones. A single market maker knows the underlying efficient price and consequently the probability of a mid-price jump in the future. She controls the volumes she quotes at the best bid and ask prices. Solving her optimization problem allows us to understand endogenously the price-imbalance connection and to confirm in particular that it is optimal to quote a predictive imbalance. Our model can also be used by a platform to select a suitable tick size, which is known to be a crucial topic in financial regulation. The value function of the market maker’s control problem can be viewed as a family of functions, indexed by the level of the market maker’s inventory, solving a coupled system of PDEs. We show existence and uniqueness of classical solutions to this coupled system of equations. In the case of a continuous inventory, we also prove uniqueness of the market maker’s optimal control policy.
Complexity vs Empirical Score
- Math Complexity: 9.5/10
- Empirical Rigor: 2.0/10
- Quadrant: Lab Rats — high math complexity, limited empirical testing
Why this score: The paper involves advanced stochastic control, PDE theory with existence/uniqueness proofs, and heavy use of measure theory and functional analysis, placing math complexity very high; however, the empirical section relies on numerical approximations of the HJB equation without backtests, real data, or implementation details, resulting in low empirical rigor.
Research Flowchart
flowchart TD A["Research Goal:<br>Analyze the relationship between<br>volume imbalance & price moves"] --> B["Methodology:<br>Market-Making Optimization Problem"] B --> C["Key Inputs & Model:<br>• Underlying efficient price<br>• Uncertainty zones for mid-price<br>• Market maker's inventory level"] C --> D["Computational Process:<br>Solve Coupled PDE System<br>(Value function V(q,t) for inventory q)"] D --> E["Theoretical Proof:<br>Existence & Uniqueness of<br>Classical Solutions"] D --> F["Optimal Policy Derivation:<br>Control of bid/ask quote volumes"] E --> G["Key Outcome 1:<br>Price-Imbalance Relationship<br>Derived endogenously from optimization"] F --> H["Key Outcome 2:<br>Predictive Imbalance<br>Confirmed as optimal strategy"] F --> I["Key Outcome 3:<br>Tick Size Selection Model<br>Framework for regulators/platforms"]
Evidence Card
What the authors claim, on what data, and who has checked it. Read from the paper's own text by a language model: every quote is verbatim, nothing was re-run. How to read this card
Proposes
The paper proposes a market‑making model in which a single market maker, who knows the underlying efficient price, controls the volumes quoted at the best bid and ask to endogenously generate a predictive volume imbalance.
Source sentence
To this end, we study a market-making problem which allows us to view the imbalance as an optimal response to price moves. In our model, there is an underlying efficient price driving the mid-price, which follows the model with uncertainty zones.
Assumes 5
- The mid‑price is driven by an underlying efficient price that follows the model with uncertainty zones. model
Source sentence
In our model, there is an underlying efficient price driving the mid-price, which follows the model with uncertainty zones.
- The market maker knows the efficient price and the probability of a future mid‑price jump. market
Source sentence
A single market maker knows the underlying efficient price and consequently the probability of a mid-price jump in the future.
- The market maker can only quote volumes at the best bid and ask (prices P±δ/2). execution
Source sentence
She controls the volumes she quotes at the best bid and ask prices. Following the interpretation at the end of Remark 1, we suppose that in the primary market, the considered stock is a large-tick stock, meaning the bid-ask spread is almost always equal to one tick, and the best quotes are placed at P ± δ 2.
- The asset is a large‑tick stock, so the bid‑ask spread is almost always one tick. market
Source sentence
Following the interpretation at the end of Remark 1, we suppose that in the primary market, the considered stock is a large-tick stock, meaning the bid-ask spread is almost always equal to one tick, and the best quotes are placed at P ± δ 2.
Show 1 more
- If the market maker quotes away from the best price, no trades occur because her price is worse than the platform’s best price. execution
Source sentence
If the market maker, on the platform where she trades, places her quote further, no one will trade with her since her price is worse than the one they would get on the other platform. Remark 4.
Data
No dataset named in the text.
Costs
Not applicable
Finds 2
- Numerical experiments show that the optimal posted volume imbalance is predictive of price moves and is a monotone function of the distance between the efficient and mid‑prices. predictive-accuracy
Source sentence
Our numerical experiments indicate that for reasonable choices of the model parameters, the optimal posted volume imbalance is predictive of price moves. More precisely, under reasonable scenarios, the optimal volume imbalance is a monotone function of the distance between the efficient and mid-prices, which in turn determine the price moves via the model with uncertainty zones.
- The paper proves existence and uniqueness of classical solutions to the coupled system of PDEs arising from the market maker’s control problem. theoretical
Source sentence
We show existence and uniqueness of classical solutions to this coupled system of equations. In the case of a continuous inventory, we also prove uniqueness of the market maker's optimal control policy.
Checked by others
No other paper in the archive has been found to support or contradict these findings (compared with 6 related papers). Coverage is partial, so this is neither replication nor refutation.
3 papers in the archive
Code
No repository by the authors found in the paper.
Extracted 2026-11-14 · same card as JSON · A language model chose these items: check the source sentence before relying on one.